Small boats can be tricky places to store the quantities of water some cruises require. Our family of four consumes at least 3 gallons per day, more in hot weather. Carrying a week’s worth of water in rigid containers would leave precious little room for our bodies and gear in our 18′ sail-and-oar pram. What’s more, hard-sided bottles make poor use of the irregular spaces where water is often best kept in small boats. Rigid containers would be difficult to secure and impossible to fit into the small, curved, awkward spaces available low in our boat where we prefer to keep such dense supplies.
Enter the soft-sided 2.6-gallon Collapsible Water Bags from WaterStorageCube. Remarkably inexpensive, they hold water securely and conform to the shape of wherever they’re stowed. They have a comfortable handle, stand upright, pour well, seal effectively, and hold about the right weight of water for adults to carry. When empty, they fold down to nearly nothing. They are BPA-free, and 1.3-gallon sizes are also available.
The four bags I’ve been using have stood up very well to a season of use. They have been mildly abused, mostly at the hands of my six-year-old son, who cannot be convinced to stop lying on them. They have been dropped, frozen, lightly trodden upon, and packed into small spaces, and still hold water.
The claims of durability from the manufacturer are not particularly quantitative: “can withstand heavy pressure & falls.” To simulate what seemed to me a realistic worst-case scenario, I held a full bag at my side as it would normally be carried and dropped it repeatedly on concrete. After seven drops, it broke in the center of its largest panel (not a seam). I’m satisfied that this is durable enough for my purposes, particularly as we carry several bags and more water than we expect to use and so have safety in redundancy.
When frozen, the water bags make excellent ice blocks for cold storage (remember to fill them only partially so that the expanding ice will not rupture the plastic). A little creativity in fill levels or their placement in your freezer should result in a block custom-fit to your intended use. Don’t use the bags for hot water storage, as the manufacturer only rates them to 140°F.
I try to minimize my environmental impact, don’t love buying plastics, and felt some guilt around purchasing and using these water bags, which are made of LDPE (low-density polyethylene), which is collected for recycling in bins found at grocery stores in some communities (not mine, unfortunately). The thin-walled semi-rigid gallon water jugs that I previously used are made of HDPE (high-density polyethylene), which is accepted in curbside recycling; these gallon jugs typically last about a year before cracking and leaking. The water bags weigh 98 grams to the gallon jugs’ 64 grams and they store 2.6 times as much water, meaning that they are using substantially less plastic per gallon. My bet is that they will also last longer than the harder plastic used in the jugs.
The bags are a safe and inexpensive way to store plenty of water in a boat’s awkward spaces, and I’m happy to have them aboard.
James Kealey lives and teaches in Richmond, California. When he’s not chasing his two young sons, he can usually be found banging away on some project in his garage workshop or sail-camping on a mountain lake.
The Premium Collapsible Water Bags from WaterStorageCube are available from its Amazon Store. A set of four 2.6-gallon bags sells for $16.96.
Is there a product that might be useful for boatbuilding, cruising, or shore-side camping that you’d like us to review? Please email your suggestions.
I have used Platypus poly bags for a number of years now. Though there are several sizes, I like the 2-liter ones. They seem tough, and last several years. I did make the mistake on a Baja kayak trip of using a small one (around a liter, I think) for unleaded gas to fuel a beach camping stove. Why a mistake? Well, it held up through the trip okay, but when I offered to donate the last bit to our driver’s gas tank, it gave up the ghost just as I finished the transfer.
I have used the 2-liter size for carrying wine, and they will hold well over two 0.75 liter bottles. They don’t seem to impart any unwanted tastes to the wine, but maybe my taste buds are not as robust as they could be (I can also sleep with a pea under my mattress).
In addition to fitting into awkward nooks while stowing, they also serve as water ballast. The advantage of water ballast is that in case of a swamping, they have neutral buoyancy, so will not take your vessel to the bottom. Obviously, that means also that they don’t provide quite as much ballast effect as denser object, but to me, they are worth the tradeoff.
Nice review. In my experience the wine (and any after-tastes) seems to ‘neutralise’ after a glass or two … after two bottles well … (not suggesting for a minute you would drink it all at once)
I’ve ordered a few 5-litre bags for my cruising dinghy adventures this summer. I think they will be really useful.
In order to assure that this sort of bag is hygienic between trips, I store them with a bit of cheap vodka in each bag. Seems to do a good job, even over the winter.
I see that you carry North Coast Brewing bottles on your boat. I’m a fan of their “Old Rasputin.”
These bags are rigid enough that they stand open and un-collapsed to dry out. They look convincingly dry after a few days, but I still store them open.
Those bottles were indeed Old Rasputin – a great beer for a cold night on a beach. Around the house when no one is looking we commit the terrible heresy of pouring it over ice cream. It makes about the most delicious desert you could imagine.
– James
I’ve used paper cups with the bottoms cut out to get air into various types of collapsible water bags to dry them out. Upside down and hanging. They keep the bag from collapsing on the spout hole.